Some of us like chocolate. Some of us like vanilla. Some of us like strawberry. Some of us like mint chocolate and some of us like peanut butter. We’re talking about milkshake flavors, of course!
If you were given a choice between a chocolate or a vanilla milkshake, which would you choose? Or do you not like either and you’d choose another flavor (only choose “other” if you really don’t like chocolate or vanilla shakes)? If you don’t like milkshakes at all, we think you’re nuts! No, we don’t, but we wish you did!


I chose neither because given the choice I would go for just about anything other than “plain ole chocolate or vanilla”. I especially like butterscotch or peach. Actually, if they only have chocolate and vanilla, I would skip it.
Definitely strawberry. I only get a milkshake maybe once a year at Culver’s and their strawberry is delicious!
Not always available, but I love pineapple milkshakes!
When I was a young (YOUNG!) sprout of a lad I thought “vanilla” was a NO FLAVOR option.
Strawberry! I haven’t had one in a LOOOOONG time!
Strawberry
I chose vanilla, but I’d rather have a Marshmellow Raspberry Malt. Just the thought brings back so many memories.
I know I’m not in the majority and my siblings insist I’m adopted as I do not care for chocolate! Give me vanilla, strawberry, fruit – anything but chocolate!
Not really a shake fan but will indulge occasionally with a Chocolate frosty to dip my Wendy’s fries in. Yum!!
I choose “yes”. For me, shakes are OK, but I really prefer malts, which few places offer anymore. Another sign of our crumbling society.
How did I forget! We always order a malt if on the menu. Like the one at Steak & Shake.
I prefer a mixture, Black & White.
I chose vanilla but only if it is full of fruit! So I guess not vanilla 🍓🍑
Prefer butterscotch… when I can find it!
I like strawberry milk shakes but I’m completely addicted to peanut butter cup blizzards…
I can’t tell you when was the last time I had a milkshake. When I do, I prefer a mocha one. I use to get one at Arby’s every time we went there.
Chocolate of course!
However, Whataburger is featuring a Banana Pudding milk shake that is excellent.
I would rather have a Strawberry or Mocha shake.
It’s been years since I had a Jamocha shake at Arbys. I may have to splurge….
I’ll take a strawberry shake……….
It’s not that I don’t like them, but being a diabetic, I had to eliminate all the sugar I can from my diet or take lots of meds.
I regret, there is never enough chocolate in the milkshake.
chocolate…all others are imposters ! Same for the “Frosties” from Wendys
Strawberry!!!
Strawberry!
Cherry
Strawberry!
Butterscotch if you can find it or strawberry.
My favorite is a black and white, same as Bill. For those that don’t know how to make one, it’s a vanilla shake with a half shot of chocolate syrup.
Prefer Strawberry Milk Shake.
I usually only splurge on a milkshake when I go out to someplace like Red Robin, and then it’s either Cookies and Cream or an adult version of a fruit based milkshake (huckleberry is a favorite). If I just want one and head to a local burger joint, then I go for Strawberry if they only have the ‘big three’.
In High School it was Cherry and since it has been Strawberry. I don’t know why?
Strawberry
Strawberry!
Blackberry!
Put me down for a non-dairy dessert in place of any ice cream.
Arby’s jamocha shake
agree…Arby’s jamocha shake
Malt for me, either chocolate or vanilla, but chocolate malt only for my wife.
I prefer vanilla but chocolate will do. I just need it to be from a real ice cream shop, not fast food joint.
Chocolate, of course. Vanilla is so vanilla. However, my real favorite is a black cow. Now that’s a treat!
Strawberry!
Yummmmmm! 🙂
Fresh raspberry
Mocha. Always mocha.