Your RV’s fire extinguisher might not function. At all. At best, the fire extinguisher that came with your RV may create a path to the doorway if there’s a fire inside, but many RV fire extinguishers are at the doorway.
You may find yourself running through fire just to pass the fire extinguisher mounted by the door. I have often criticized many Class A motorhomes for having poor fire escapes, but almost all RVs have lousy fire extinguishers.
I was recently made more aware of the situation with RV fire extinguishers after my friends from Airstream Life sent me an Element Fire Extinguisher. Rich and Cheryl are people I’ve met at several rallies and events and they knew I would be intrigued by this. I am.
Being the geek that I am, I wanted to know more about this product so I arranged to talk to Rob Calisi, who works as the importer of these to the US. The Element is a product that was designed in Italy as something for soldiers to use to put out fires.
Unlike any fire extinguisher that you’ll find in an RV, this one does not have an expiration date. That’s because it works much differently than the fire extinguisher that came with your RV.
How fire extinguishers work
The fire extinguishers that most of us have seen work by having a substance inside them that is propelled outward when we release it. The idea is to shoot this stuff at the base of the fire to, essentially, suffocate it.
What happens is that you create a big white mess when you do this, although that’s certainly better than your RV burning down. If you’re able to stop the fire.
Most of us haven’t ever used a fire extinguisher, so Calisi stated that many people spend the first few moments in a panic and waste a portion of the contents of the fire extinguisher. Clearly you’re in a situation that is stressful.
The contents inside a traditional fire extinguisher are rated for what they’re intended to extinguish. There’s a guide at the end of this article, but many RVs I’ve seen have the white extinguisher which is rated to tackle A, B and C fire designations.
What happens to RV fire extinguishers
I had written that your fire extinguisher might not work. This is true even if the dial on the extinguisher shows that it’s okay.
Over time, for example, the shaking and jarring that your RV experiences can compress the material in the fire extinguisher. Think of how compacted some of your spices are. Same situation.
Another thing Calisi said is that condensation can occur inside the fire extinguisher which acts to turn the powder in the extinguisher into something like concrete. There may be pressure still in the extinguisher, but it can’t distribute the now-hardened material.
Another thing—the traditional fire extinguisher only has about 9-11 seconds of discharge capability. That’s not long.
How the Element works
The Element fire extinguisher works by your activating a process that chemically disrupts the oxygen that a flame needs. Because of the way the process works, it doesn’t create a mess and can work on all types of fires.
It also doesn’t take oxygen out of the equation, so it’s safe to breathe, according to the company. It’s also non-toxic.
I did not light my Element Fire Extinguisher to try it out, first of all. But I did watch a bunch of videos and I can liken the action to something like a flare. In fact, it looks a lot like a flare. It even functions much like one where you take the cap off, strike the surface and enable the chemical reaction.
I also like how small this device is. We have one mounted near our bed and will actually put one in our truck (we’ve ordered it; it hasn’t arrived yet).
Like a flare, it keeps going. My wife had the idea of taking one of these and lobbing it into an engine compartment or baggage compartment if it happened to catch fire. I laughed. Calisi thought it was a great idea.
Shows you what I know.
There are also very explicit pictograms on the side of the unit. They’re large enough that even I can follow them without glasses on. That’s important in the middle of the night.
What do the fire extinguisher letters mean
The letters on a fire extinguisher directly correlate with the type of fire it’s designed to tackle.
Class A: The fire you’re most likely to encounter. Class A means common combustibles like paper, plastic, wood, cloth, etc., are fueling the fire. Classic Class A fire extinguishers use simple pressurized water to suppress these simple fires, although most fire extinguishers capable of dealing with a Class A are multi-class and can extinguish multiple kinds of fire.
Class B: While water is effective at fighting many types of fires, Class B fires require something a little different. When a fire is driven by flammable liquids like petroleum oil, gasoline, paint, and gases such as butane and propane, water is both useless and dangerous. Spraying water on one of these can cause it to rapidly spread and increase damage.
Class B fire extinguishers are often foam based, using the foam to smother the fire by taking away the oxygen.
Class C: These fires are caused by electricity and electrical equipment and also require a distinct extinguisher. Fires are only considered class C if electricity is still actively flowing to the item that is on fire. Once it’s shut off, the fire ceases to be considered a Class C.
The most common type of extinguisher, a dry chemical-based one, is ideal for fighting electrical fires. It’s even effective on A and B fires, although much more so on B and C than on A.
Class D: Some fires require extremely specific care, and among these are Class D fires which are caused by combustible metals like magnesium. While you probably won’t face this in your home or office, Class D fires are a hazard faced by workers in labs and manufacturing plants.
Average fire extinguishers will have no effect on Class D fires. To properly be extinguished, they use a dry powder-based extinguisher to put out the flames. This powder is perfectly suited for metal fires but is not effective against conventional combustibles.
Class K: You might know Class K fires simply as “grease fires.” They’re caused when oils and fats used in cooking are set alight and require special care when extinguishing. Water will make this type of fire far worse, and some extinguisher residue can damage cooking equipment. Class K extinguishers are meant to be easy to clean up after and are effective against grease fires.
RV fires in summary
If you haven’t yet, watch Marc and Julie Bennett’s video about how quickly an RV fire can spread. It’s really eye-opening.
I also like this Element fire extinguisher. If nothing else, it is small enough to be mounted conveniently and may help you get out in a fire.
Another product I am a huge advocate of is the ProTeng® fire suppression system. This is a system that requires no intervention by the user to put out a fire and is permanently mounted in engine bays and behind RV refrigerators.
I’m a bit of a nut regarding fire as I have a number of friends who are firefighters. After a few beers, I hear stories. None of them are pretty.
So I hope whatever you do helps you stay safe and, if you want to see the Element Fire Extinguishers, I’ll be at the FROG rally and then the FMCA convention. We won’t light the extinguisher but I will show it to you. How’s that?
##GRVA10




I’m questioning the Element fire extinguisher. Is it legal in the U.S.? does it have the required UL approval, FM approval and US tested ratings?! Just my experience and a question to the curious.
Yes, perfectly legal. Otherwise I don’t think they would be marketing the heck out of it. Plus I tend not to write reviews of products that are prohibited for sale.
The article title “The Element Fire Extinguisher” leads the reader to suppose the article is about the Element Fire Extinguisher. Your article is, in effect, a primer of fires. You don’t tell the reader diddly squat (note my linguistic restraint) about the fire extinguisher; for example, how much does it cost, where to buy, or how to use (throw it into the baggage compartment?).
Guess you didn’t watch the video. It answers all the issues you mentioned. For where to buy: it shows their web site so I would start there.
It would have been nice if they would have put out a fire with it.
They’re too expensive to waste one is why! lol
We saw the Jay Leno video of these when it first came out and immediately purchased one for bedroom, one for kitchen, and one for truck. Love that they don’t expire and appear to be easy to use as, thank goodness, we have not needed to use them😊
The Element intrigued me, so I looked at a couple of YouTube videos. I concluded it’s best for enclosed spaces, since any wind quickly disperses the gas. Also, you have to get very close to the fire, potentially subjecting you to heat or smoke injury. I guess it’s better than nothing, but I’ll stick with my dry chemical extinguisher…
I think you’re looking at this all wrong. Of course it’s designed for enclosed spaces, that’s where the danger comes from. It’s not designed to put out camp fires or other outdoor fires. Usually one is not trapped if they are outside. As for getting very close to a fire, you have to get close with a dry chemical extinguisher too. In fact, you have to get closer with one. With the Element extinguisher, you could toss it into a enclosed space fire and leave. With the dry chemical extinguisher, you have to stay in contact with the fire and you have to continuously squeeze the trigger.
Thank you, Tony! 🙂 I have contemplated ProTeng. If #2 RV is it, as in the last one, then I will lobby for one in a year or two. At that point we will know if there will be a #3 or not. Meanwhile, this fire extinguisher looks pretty good. Thanks again, have a great day, and safe travels! 🙂
From what I’m reading, the Element is legitimate and thus expensive. You get what you pay for.
This got me thinking about automatic fire extinguishers.
Most of these type products are questionable. They may claim to meet UL standards but for Chinese companies this is dubious.
“The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission says Elide fire-extinguishing balls can fail to extinguish a fire, leaving people at risk of injury and death.”
https://www.wate.com/news/fire-extinguishing-ball-may-fail-to-actually-extinguish-fires-cpsc-warns/
The Proteng is made in the USA and expensive and used by companies and government, so it actually works.
Thanks, John. Here’s a link to an article about RV fires and Proteng from Mike Sokol, back when he wrote for us and when Proteng first became available. It also contains a video about Proteng. Have a great day. 😀 –Diane at RVtravel.com